Famesick vs I'm Glad My Mom Died — Two Memoirs That Broke the Internet

Two women. Two childhoods stolen by fame. Two memoirs that made the internet stop scrolling and actually feel something.

Lena Dunham's Famesick (2026) and Jennette McCurdy's I'm Glad My Mom Died (2022) are the two most talked-about celebrity memoirs of recent years — and as audiobooks, they hit completely differently than reading them on the page. Both authors narrate their own stories. Both are brutally, uncomfortably honest. And both are available on Audible.

But which one should you listen to first, and which audiobook experience is likely to suit you better? This comparison weighs the narration, production, author performance, listener response and available reviews so you do not have to choose blind.

The Hook: Fame Made Them Famous — But Also Broke Them

The reason these two books belong together is simple: they're both about the same wound, told from different angles.

Jennette McCurdy was the star of iCarly and Sam & Cat — a Nickelodeon kid who grew up on camera while her mother pushed, controlled, and ultimately consumed her. I'm Glad My Mom Died is the story of what that does to a person, told with a clarity that is almost shocking in its directness.

Lena Dunham was the creator and star of Girls — a different kind of fame, more critically acclaimed, more culturally contested. Famesick is her reckoning with what it means to be famous before you know who you are, and what it costs to try to find out after the cameras stop.

Both books are about emotional damage. Both are about mothers (in very different ways). Both are about trying to become a real person after being a public one first. The difference is in tone, structure, and what each author has made peace with — and what they haven't.

Famesick by Lena Dunham — The Audiobook

Narrated by: Lena Dunham
Length: Approx. 10 hours
Published: April 2026
Genre: Memoir / Biography
Chart position: #1 US Audiobook Chart (April 2026)

Dunham's voice on audio is exactly what you'd expect if you've ever heard her speak — fast, digressive, self-aware to the point of self-parody, and then suddenly, unexpectedly raw. She writes the way she thinks, which means Famesick as an audiobook is a chaotic, funny, deeply uncomfortable experience that occasionally stops you cold.

The book covers her rise to fame with Girls, the cultural backlash, her health struggles, her relationships, and the particular kind of identity crisis that comes from being famous for being yourself when you're not sure who that self actually is. It's more reflective and less linear than McCurdy's book — less a narrative and more a reckoning.

As an audiobook: Dunham's self-narration is the whole point. There are moments where her voice cracks slightly, or where she rushes through something painful, that you simply cannot get from the page. It rewards close listening. It also rewards patience — this is not a tightly plotted memoir. It meanders, circles back, contradicts itself. That's either a feature or a bug depending on what you're looking for.

Best for: Listeners who loved Girls, who are interested in the cultural conversation around fame and feminism, or who want a memoir that feels like a long, honest conversation with someone who has been through it.

I'm Glad My Mom Died by Jennette McCurdy — The Audiobook

Narrated by: Jennette McCurdy
Length: 6 hours 15 minutes
Published: August 2022
Genre: Memoir / Biography
Status: Perennial bestseller — still in the top 100 four years after release

McCurdy's memoir is darker, tighter, and more structurally controlled than Dunham's. It reads — and listens — like a thriller. Short chapters. Punchy sentences. A relentless forward momentum that makes it almost impossible to stop. She covers her childhood as a Nickelodeon child star, her mother's emotional abuse and eating disorder manipulation, and her own long road to recovery with a precision that is both devastating and, somehow, often very funny.

The title is the hook — and the book delivers on it completely. By the time you reach the end, you understand exactly why she means it, and you feel it alongside her.

As an audiobook: McCurdy's narration is extraordinary. She voices her mother with a particular flatness that is more chilling than any dramatic reading could be. The short chapters work brilliantly on audio — each one lands like a gut punch, and then there's a moment of silence before the next one begins. It's one of the best-narrated memoirs available on Audible.

Best for: Anyone. Genuinely. This is the audiobook you recommend to people who say they don't like audiobooks. It's that good.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Category	Famesick	I'm Glad My Mom Died
Tone	Reflective, chaotic, funny	Dark, precise, darkly funny
Structure	Non-linear, essay-like	Tight, thriller-paced chapters
Narration	Raw, fast, self-aware	Controlled, devastating, brilliant
Length	~10 hours	6 hrs 15 min
Emotional impact	High — builds slowly	Immediate and relentless
Best for	Girls fans, cultural memoir lovers	Everyone — especially audiobook newcomers

The Verdict: Which Should You Listen to First?

If you've never listened to an audiobook before — or if you're trying to convince someone else to start — start with I'm Glad My Mom Died. It's shorter, faster, and one of the most compelling audiobook experiences available anywhere. McCurdy's narration is a masterclass. You will not be able to stop.

If you've already listened to McCurdy's book — or if you're a Lena Dunham fan, or you want something more expansive and essayistic — Famesick is your next listen. It's messier and more demanding, but it rewards the investment.

The good news? With your Audible free trial, you get one audiobook completely free. Listen to one now, and the other is waiting for you when you're ready.

Get Both Free on Audible

Both Famesick and I'm Glad My Mom Died are available on Audible right now. With your current Audible trial offer, you get an audiobook benefit where included in the current offer — even if you cancel before the trial ends. Start with whichever one calls to you. The other one will be waiting.

Check the current Audible offer for your country and account and get a complimentary audiobook where included in the offer even if you cancel →

---

Affiliate disclaimer: This article contains affiliate links. If you sign up for an Audible trial through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend books and services we genuinely believe in.